Water Lilies, Night Effect
From the Whatifs Catalogue, the encyclopedia of paintings that never were
Water Lilies, Night Effect is an imagined painting attributed, within the Whatifs fiction, to Claude Monet (1917). It belongs to the Whatifs series of works the great masters never painted.
History and rediscovery
Monet always claimed he never painted at night. Yet a letter to Clemenceau mentions "a folly made by lantern light". Given to a Giverny neighbour, the canvas spent a century rolled up behind tools in a barn. Found during a probate sale in 2023, it is the painter's only known nocturne.
Sale
Within the fiction, the painting sold for €97,000,000 (2024). Tap the board to replay the imagined bidding. The auction pictured below never took place.

See also
- Self-Portrait, Laughing Out Loud, Rembrandt
- The Refused Kiss, Gustav Klimt
- The Old Port of Marseille, Vincent van Gogh
Notes
- Image generated with AI from a prompt written by Whatifs. No real painting, signature or auction house is reproduced.
- Story written for Whatifs. Any resemblance to real discoveries is coincidental.
